The Problem With “You Should Just Know”



🌿 Welcome Back to The Reset Room

If you’re new here — welcome.
Each week in The Reset Room, we pause together for a small shift in thinking that can reset patterns in our lives and relationships.

Over the past couple weeks we’ve been exploring a theme many of you responded strongly to.

First, we talked about direct communication — learning to say what we need instead of hinting and hoping people read our minds.

Last week we explored how our brains build neural pathways that shape how we interpret other people’s words and actions.

And today we’re looking at something that quietly grows out of those two things:

Passive-aggressive communication.

It’s something almost everyone has done at some point — often without realizing it.


🌟 A Quick Story From the Therapy Room

During a couples session recently, one partner said something that stopped the room for a moment.

She said:

“I shouldn’t have to tell you what I need. You should just know.”

Her partner looked frustrated and responded:

“But I don’t know. I’m trying.”

This is a moment I see often in therapy, both couples and individuals who come in with hurt feelings.

They feel hurt because their needs weren’t met.

The other person likely feels confused because they didn’t know there was a need in the first place.

So instead of saying the need directly, the hurt partner/friend begins communicating in other ways:

• quiet withdrawal
• subtle comments
• sarcasm
• short answers
• “It’s fine.”

And underneath it all is the same message:

“I wish you would just understand.”

But the truth is, most people don’t interpret hints the same way we intend them.


🧠 Where Passive-Aggressive Communication Comes From

Remember the neural pathways we talked about last week?

Our brains are constantly interpreting situations based on past experiences and how we store them.

So when we feel hurt or disappointed, our brain often jumps quickly to a story like:

• “They should know better.”
• “If they cared, they’d notice.”
• “I shouldn’t have to ask.”

Instead of expressing the need directly, the brain tries to protect us from vulnerability or coming across as "needy".

And that protection often shows up as indirect communication.

The problem is…

Indirect communication rarely solves the problem.

It usually creates more confusion and more resentment.


🌾 What Passive-Aggressive Communication Looks Like

Passive-aggressive communication is rarely loud.

It’s subtle.

Sometimes it sounds like:

• “Whatever you want.”
• “It doesn’t matter.”
• “I guess I’ll just do it myself.”
• “It must be nice to have time for that.”

Other times it shows up through behavior:

• withdrawing
• being distant
• procrastinating on something intentionally
• making sarcastic comments

Underneath it all is often the same unmet need:

“I wish you understood what I need without me having to say it.”

👇🏻 Read Coparenting Reset or skip down for More RESET tips

🧭 Coparenting RESET

Passive-aggressive communication can easily appear in coparenting relationships, especially when tension or past conflict exists and can even show up with the children.

A coparent might say something like:

“Well, if you think that’s best…”

But the tone and context suggest frustration.

Or a parent might say in front of the child:

“I guess your other parent didn’t tell you about the schedule change.”

These comments may feel small in the moment, but children often pick up on the tension between the lines.

A healthier reset in coparenting communication is asking:

“Am I saying what I actually need… or hoping they figure it out?”

Direct communication protects both the parent relationship and the child’s emotional space.


🔄 This Week’s RESET

The next time you notice frustration building or disappointment in a relationship, pause and ask yourself:

1️⃣ What am I hoping this person will understand?

2️⃣ Have I actually said that out loud?

3️⃣ What would it sound like if I expressed it clearly?

For example:

Instead of:

“You never help around here.”

Try:

“I feel overwhelmed tonight. Could you help with the dishes?”

Clear communication may feel vulnerable in the moment because they could say "no".

But it almost always leads to better outcomes than hinting.


🧘 A Short Reset Practice

When you feel the urge to make a sarcastic comment or withdraw, pause and take one slow breath.

Then ask yourself:

“What do I actually need right now?”

If possible, say that need directly.

Even simple statements like:

• “I'm not sure why but I felt hurt when that happened.”
• “I could use a little help tonight if you are able.”
• “I was hoping for you to ask me but never really let you know I wanted to go.”

can change the direction of a conversation as it keeps accusation low and understanding HIGH.


💡 A Thought to Carry With You

Passive-aggressive communication often starts with an understandable feeling:

disappointment.

But when disappointment isn’t expressed clearly, it often turns into resentment, a passive-aggressive action and then strain in the relationship with no resolve.

The reset happens when we choose gentle clarity without negative tone over hints.


🌱 Coming Next Week

Once we begin communicating more directly, another important question comes up:

What are healthy expectations in relationships?

How do we ask for what we need without expecting people to read our minds…
and without feeling like we’re asking for too much?

Next week in The Reset Room, we’ll explore the difference between:

✨ healthy expectations
and
✨ silent tests people don’t know they’re taking.

If this issue resonated with you, consider sharing it with someone who might benefit from the reset too.

Sometimes the smallest shifts in communication create the biggest changes in relationships.

Let me know how you have changed your tactics or even maybe have become more mindful of how you are communicating to people around you?

I would love for you to practice on me by hitting reply and sharing one recent disappointment you had that is stewing inside of you, who it was with (a friend/spouse/child/coworker), and then your idea of a direct way to share it with them using the above-method in order to create understanding. I will then respond with a thumbs up or a tweak of something I feel might be better.

Until next week!

🤗-Tina

Tina Souder, M.Ed., LPC-S

I’m a counselor, counselor supervisor, and parenting facilitator/coordinator passionate about mental health — especially when it comes to helping families navigate coparenting. My focus is on reducing the stress and conflict that can impact both adults and children. Subscribe and join over 1,000+ newsletter readers each week.

Read more from Tina Souder, M.Ed., LPC-S

🌿 Welcome Back to The Reset Room If you’re new here — welcome.Each week in The Reset Room, we pause together for a small shift in thinking that can help reset patterns in our lives and relationships. Over the past few weeks we’ve been exploring something many of you said resonated deeply — communication in relationships. First, we talked about the importance of saying what we need clearly instead of hinting. Then we explored how our brains build neural pathways that shape how we interpret...

🌿 Welcome to The Reset Room If you are new here — welcome.Each week in The Reset Room, we pause together for a small mindset shift that helps us reset patterns in our lives, relationships, and thinking. Last week we talked about the importance of direct communication — using clear I-statements instead of hinting and hoping people read our minds. After that issue went out, I received a surprising number of responses from readers who said: “This is one of the hardest things for me in my...

🌿 Welcome Back to The Reset Room If you’re new here — welcome.Each week we gently reset something that may be quietly shaping your relationships, your stress level, or your peace. 🤔 Let’s Start Here… Most people would never describe themselves as passive-aggressive. But most people have done passive-aggressive things. Here’s the twist: When we do it →We think we’re being patient. Kind. Avoiding drama. When others do it →We call it manipulation. That gap?That’s where growth lives. 😂 Be honest....