What if YOUR Defensiveness IS the Problem?


🌿 Welcome Back to The Reset Room

Last week, we talked about how communication can either build connection… or slowly break it down.

This week, we’re going deeper into something that quietly destroys connection faster than almost anything else:

👉 Defensiveness


🌟 A Moment From the Therapy Room

I recently had a couple in session practicing a simple (but powerful) exercise:

One partner would share:
👉 “Something I need more (or less) of from you…”

The other partner had one job only:
👉 Listen… and reflect back what they heard.
(No defending. No explaining. No correcting.)

Sounds simple, right?

It wasn’t.

One partner struggled every single time.
Before they could even reflect back what was said… they jumped in to defend themselves.

“I didn’t mean it like that…”
“That’s not what I was doing…”
“Well you do that too…”

I had to gently stop them—over and over—and bring them back to the exercise.

And then something powerful happened…

At the end of the session, that same partner was in tears.

Because for the first time,
👉 they actually heard their partner… instead of preparing to defend.

And what they said next was everything:

“I don’t feel attacked anymore… I actually understand now. And I want to do better.”

That’s the shift.


🧠 What’s Actually Happening When You Get Defensive

Defensiveness doesn’t start with your words.
It starts internally.

Your brain quickly scans for danger:
👉 “Am I being blamed?”
👉 “Am I about to be misunderstood?”
👉 “Am I about to lose respect?”

And in a split second, your nervous system moves into protection mode.

  • Your tone sharpens
  • Your body tightens
  • Your mind starts building a case

Before you’ve even fully processed what was said…
👉 you’re already responding

For many people, this is:

  • A learned habit
  • A modeled behavior growing up
  • Or even a trauma response

And underneath it all is often a belief like:
👉 “If I don’t defend myself… I’ll be walked all over.”


⚠️ The Problem With That Belief

Because here’s what actually happens when you react defensively:

Scenario:

Your partner says:
👉 “I feel like you’ve been really distant this week.”

Defensive Response:
“Distant?? I’ve been working nonstop! You have no idea what my week has been like. And honestly, you’ve been off too!”

What just happened internally:

  • Brain detected threat → “I’m being blamed”
  • Nervous system activated → protect, justify, counter

What happened externally:

  • Your partner no longer feels heard
  • They feel dismissed or criticized back
  • They shut down or escalate

👉 Connection breaks


🔁 Now Watch The Reset

Same situation:

👉 “I feel like you’ve been really distant this week.”

Regulated Response:
“Okay… I hear you saying you’ve felt some distance from me this week. Is that right?” (pause...let them confirm)

Or if that is too many words for you... just a simple,

"Okay?" (pause… )

“Can you tell me a little more about when you felt that?”

What just happened internally:

  • You noticed the urge to defend… and didn’t act on it
  • You slowed the reaction
  • You stayed grounded instead of reactive

What happened externally:

  • They feel heard
  • Their guard lowers
  • They open up more

And now… when you share your side:

👉 “I can see how it looked that way. This week was heavy for me, but I don’t want you feeling disconnected from me.”

Now you’re not defending…

👉 You’re connecting


💡 The Reframe That Changes Everything

What if not reacting immediately…

👉 isn’t weakness
👉 isn’t letting someone walk all over you

What if it’s actually:

✔️ Emotional strength
✔️ Self-control
✔️ Leadership in the relationship

Because when you stay calm and respond intentionally:

  • You preserve the relationship
  • You build self-respect
  • And you often gain more respect from others

Not less.


🧩 A Hard Truth I See Often

If someone in your life feels:

  • distant
  • guarded
  • frustrated
  • or like they “just don’t share anymore”

…it may not be because they don’t care.

👉 It may be because they’ve learned it doesn’t feel safe to share with you.

Because every time they try…

👉 they’re met with defensiveness instead of understanding

👇🏻Read the Coparent RESET or scroll down for final RESET.


🤝 Co-Parenting Reset

This shows up powerfully in co-parenting.

I hear it all the time:
👉 “They never communicate with me.”

But when we slow it down and look closer…

Scenario:

One co-parent sends a message:
👉 “Hey, I think our child has been really overwhelmed with the schedule lately.”

Defensive Response:
“Overwhelmed? That’s ridiculous. They’re fine at my house. You’re always trying to make me look like the problem.”

What happens next:

  • Communication shuts down
  • Messages get shorter or stop altogether
  • Resentment builds
  • The child stays stuck in the middle

Now… same situation with a reset:

Regulated Response:
“Okay… you’re noticing they seem overwhelmed with the schedule?”

(pause)

“Can you tell me what you’ve been seeing?”

👉 Now you’ve:

  • lowered conflict
  • opened communication
  • and shifted toward problem-solving

And here’s the hard truth:

👉 If your co-parent has stopped communicating openly…
it may not be because they don’t care.

👉 It may be because they’re trying to avoid the reaction they’ve received in the past.


🔄 Your Reset This Week

When you feel that urge to defend… try this:

  1. Pause (even 3–5 seconds)
  2. Reflect back what you heard
  3. Ask one curious question before explaining yourself

You’re not agreeing.
You’re not losing your voice.

👉 You’re creating space for understanding first


✨ It Can Change Everything

That moment I watched in session?

That shift from:
👉 “I need to defend myself”
to
👉 “I actually understand you now”

…that’s where relationships heal.

And it’s available to you too.


👀 Next Week…

But what about when the other person is actually being disrespectful?

👉 Name-calling
👉 Cussing
👉 Crossing the line

Do you still stay calm then?

Next week, we’re breaking down:
👉 How to respond when calm doesn’t feel enough… and boundaries are necessary


💬 I’d Love To Hear From You

On a scale of 1–10…

👉 How quickly do you notice yourself getting defensive in conversations?

And be honest with me—

👉 Do you tend to defend… or withdraw?

Hit reply and tell me.
I read every response.

The newsletter is growing and I would ❤️ for you to share it with others. Forward this to them. If someone forwarded this to you.. click HERE to sign up to not miss future weekly resets to your inbox.

🤗--Tina

Tina Souder, M.Ed., LPC-S

I’m a counselor, counselor supervisor, and parenting facilitator/coordinator passionate about mental health — especially when it comes to helping families navigate coparenting. My focus is on reducing the stress and conflict that can impact both adults and children. Subscribe and join over 1,000+ newsletter readers each week.

Read more from Tina Souder, M.Ed., LPC-S

🌿 Welcome Back to The Reset Room If you’re new here—WELCOME.Each week, this is your space to pause, reflect, and reset patterns that may be quietly impacting your life and relationships more than you realize. Last week, we talked about how indirect communication and “hint dropping” creates disappointment and distance. This week… we’re going to explore defensiveness. You may be saying, Tina... but when I speak up it backfires on me because the other person seems to always get offended or...

🌿 Welcome Back to The Reset Room If you’re new here — welcome.Each week in The Reset Room, we pause together for a small shift in thinking that can help reset patterns in our lives and relationships. Over the past few weeks we’ve been exploring something many of you said resonated deeply — communication in relationships. First, we talked about the importance of saying what we need clearly instead of hinting. Then we explored how our brains build neural pathways that shape how we interpret...

🌿 Welcome Back to The Reset Room If you’re new here — welcome.Each week in The Reset Room, we pause together for a small shift in thinking that can reset patterns in our lives and relationships. Over the past couple weeks we’ve been exploring a theme many of you responded strongly to. First, we talked about direct communication — learning to say what we need instead of hinting and hoping people read our minds. Last week we explored how our brains build neural pathways that shape how we...